Forest Service Proposes Non-Native Invasive Species Plan With Herbicide Use
Dominant
Brandt MannchenThe National Forests and Grasslands in Texas (NFGT)
has proposed a Non-Native Invasive Species (NNIS) management plan. The Houston Regional
Group and Lone Star Chapter of the Sierra Club provided comments on the proposal. Some of
the comments included:
1) The obvious intent of the plan is that herbicide use will increase immensely and
that use of herbicides will be a first choice priority rather than one tool in the
Integrated Pest Management (IPM) tool box. The Sierra Club is very concerned about this
dominant use philosophy.
2) An environmental impact statement (EIS) must be prepared since this proposal is a
"major federal action which significantly affects the quality of the human
environment". The need for an EIS is reinforced by the potential impacts this
proposal will have on Wilderness areas and Wilderness character; proposed, endangered,
threatened, and sensitive (PETS) plant and animal species; human health; the ability to
recreate and recreate safety in many areas of the NFGT; the potential for spills and
unauthorized uses of poisons (herbicides); and ground and surface water quality, aquifer
recharge areas, and aquatic habitat contamination.
3) The Wilderness Act requires that areas designated by the U.S. Congress as Wilderness
be treated differently with respect to management. In fact the Wilderness Act is based on
limiting human manipulation and management (trammeling) as much as possible.
The Sierra Club is very concerned that the FS does not differentiate management of
Wilderness Areas in comparison with management with the rest of the NFGT. This is illegal
and the FS must address how management of Wilderness is different from the management of
other lands in the NFGT and how this will be implemented in the plan.
The Houston Regional Group and the Lone Star Chapter of the Sierra Club will monitor
this proposal and provide additional comments.
May 2007 |